PLAYER OF THE MONTH | OCTOBER 2026

After a sluggish start, Everton rounded out the month of October with a massive victory over Newcastle in the Carabao Cup. The victory put the blues into the quarterfinal of the Carabao Cup to face League Two Fleetwood Town. It was not the most sterling of months, but the victory has put Everton back on track, and have had an electric start to the month of November. However, with October done and dusted, The Toffee Blues Contributors voted, and here is their picks for Everton’s Player of the Month for October. 

JAMES GARNER / HARRISON ARMSTRONG (T-4TH 1 VOTE) 

James Garner, despite perhaps not yet reaching the levels he demonstrated in Everton’s last campaign, has shown his importance to the team as a mainstay in David Moyes’ side. He scored a brilliant goal against Newcastle in the cup, and started all four fixtures in the month, never leaving the pitch. He continues to be a workhorse around the pitch, registering seven tackles, seven clearances, and two interceptions from midfield. If Garner continues to see his levels increase, the midfield could improve on their above average start to the Premier League campaign and turn into one of the strongest in England.

Harrison Armstrong started all three league fixtures in the month of October, and registered in appearance as a substitute in Everton’s lone win of the month against Newcastle in the Cup. He has had his share of struggles as a young midfielder playing a boatload of minutes in the Premier League, but has shown his willingness to put in the hard yards and a knack for putting in a crunching slide tackle. He had some truly eye-popping defensive numbers as well, logging eight tackles, nine clearances, three interceptions, and winning 19 duels in the midfield. There continue to be questions about how the starting three midfielders work together, but it is clear that Armstrong is a superbly talented player, and Everton will need his contributions as the campaign ramps up and fixtures begin to pile up.

JAMES TARKOWSKI – (3RD | 5 VOTES)

Everton’s central defender, and club captain, has enjoyed somewhat of a renaissance this campaign. After struggling for spells last season alongside Michael Keane, Tarkowski has looked much more at home in an Everton side where he regularly partners with Branthwaite and O’Brien. It is no secret that when your best players play together, the results tend to get better. That story has not changed for Tarkowski through the month of October. He started and finished every match in the month of October, and made 23 clearances, won 15 aerial duels, and had seven interceptions, five tackles and eight blocked shots. His composure and availability continues to soothe nerves as Branthwaite continues to pick up small knocks, and O’Brien is oft deputised out wide for Moyes’ backline. There is something to be said for having a consistent, and available performer on your backline.

DEWSBURY-HALL – (2ND | 7 VOTES) 

Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall of Everton reacts to beating Newcastle (Photo by Tony McArdle/Eveton FC via Getty Images)
Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall of Everton reacts to beating Newcastle (Photo by Tony McArdle/Eveton FC via Getty Images)

Dewsbury-Hall has made a case this campaign that he may just be the best individual performer in an Everton kit. He continued to show his quality in October, registering a goal and two assists, with two of his three goal contributions coming in a back and forth affair against Hull City. His second assist came in the Cup match against Newcastle, where he broke down the left-hand side of the pitch and procided the service for Barry to finish off the match. He had an eye-watering nine key passes for the blues in his four matches, and his chance creation continues to be a key pillar of Everton’s success. It has often seem like when the blues need a moment of quality, they have been able to rely on the number eight in the midfield. His ability to maintain his high level of play, and not see a dip in form similar to the conclusion of last campaign, will be crucial should Everton hope to win a Cup or play in Europe next year.

THIERNO BARRY – (1ST | 8 VOTES) 

Thierno Barry of Everton celebrates after scoring (Photo by Richard Sellers/Sportsphoto/Allstar via Getty Images)
Thierno Barry of Everton celebrates after scoring (Photo by Richard Sellers/Sportsphoto/Allstar via Getty Images)

Perhaps one of the most polarizing figures in the Premier League right now, and even in the blue half of Liverpool, Theirno Barry has proven one thing, and that is an ability to consistently score goals. Quickly becoming a fan favorite with off the wall celebrations, he provided the club with another two goals and an assist in the month of October. A brilliant finish against Hull following an interception by Dewsbury-Hall, a rather surprisingly well-taken assist to give Hayden Hackney his first goal for the club against Newcaslte, and the dagger third goal in the same match to put Everton into the hat for the Quarterfinal.

Much will be said about the missed opportunities in front of goal, and perhaps that will improve with time, but what is undeniable is that Eevrton’s man up front has provided a consistent goal scoring threat the likes of which Merseyside has not seen since Calvert-Lewin produced a career year under Carlo Ancelotti. There is perhaps areas for improvement, but his improvement in the fundamental and gritty portions of matches has been undeniable. His hold-up play, aerial prowess, and ability to get the attack moving forward has improved dramatically from last season. Not to spoil the fun, but I predict we will likely see the big man back atop the list come the November Player of the Month voting. Thiero barry is the Toffee Blues’ Player of the Month for the month of October.

About The Author

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Verified by MonsterInsights